Buying Guide

Best 4 Slice Toasters – 7 Info-Packed Reviews

Disclaimer: Without conscious bias, we independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Toast can be very personal. My preference is for a light brown bread color, but my boyfriend prefers charred bread. This makes me question my character daily. The more people you have to toast with, the more choices you will have. All of this to say, selecting the right toaster for your kitchen is an important decision.

There are many models to choose from when it comes to best toasters. Toasters with four slices take up less space than their two-slice counterparts. This makes them worth looking at even if you don’t need four slices. They come in many shapes so be sure to find the right one for you. To ensure that your toast is as large and delicious as possible, you’ll need to check the settings and size of the slots. A small toaster can make it difficult to fit a large waffle or bagel into the slot.

This is our top-rated list of four-slice toasters.

Quick List of the Best 4 Slice Toasters:

(Click on the arrow ( ) if you would like to jump to section)  :

How to choose a 4-slice Toaster

Shade settings – Shade settings can be used to indicate the time the toaster will heat up before it stops. However, this is not always the case. They indicate the degree of browning – 1 may be lightly toasted, 5 might be well charred. You have a better chance of finding the perfect toast match if you dial in more numbers.

Slots-Look out for slots with adjustable widths that can be used to compress your breads as the lever lowers. This will allow you to toast all types of breads evenly and fully, even thicker bagels.

High lift – This feature allows you to push your toast higher than the natural height after popping.

Crumb tray- Most toasters come with a removable tray. This is usually hidden around the base and collects all crumbs as you toast.

The complete List of the Best 4 Slice Toasters

Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster, Brushed Stainless

Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster, Brushed StainlessSpecifications :

  • Pattern Name: Toaster
  • Brand: Cuisinart
  • Style: 4 Slice-New
  • Color: Brushed Stainless
  • Material: Stainless Steel
  • Item Dimensions: 11.15 x 10.65 x 7.5 inches
  • Item Weight: 6.1 Pounds

Check Price on Amazon


Cuisinart is a strong presence in the kitchenware vertical. With toasters such as this 4-slice model it’s easy for anyone to see why. The stainless steel brushed chassis looks great on the counter. It’s also durable and built to last. The 6 available shades allow you to personalize your toast. You can customize your toast with as little fuss as possible.

Toasting thicker breads should not be a problem as the slots are extra wide. The dedicated space is perfect for bagels lovers. It produces great results, and doesn’t scorch one side of your bagel. Cuisinart will only heat one side of your bagel so that it remains soft and chewy underneath. The toaster is extremely easy to use and the LED indicators make it easy to see what you need. You can purchase with confidence knowing that your toaster is covered by a 3-year warranty.

What we liked:

  • Finish:  We like that this toaster is made from Stainless steel with a chrome finish. This adds a stylish design which makes the toaster fit into any space.
  • Versatility: Toaster handles bread, bagels and waffles just fine, toasting on each side unjust the outside as other ovens do.

What we didn’t like:

  • Does not toast evenly: Verified purchaser complained that after only a few months the toaster started to run at half its original heat causing the bread to be too  toast unevenly.
  • Undesirable Odor:Some customers complained of the smell of burnt plastic coming from the toaster oven. Of couse this is undesirable as this burnt smell will transfer to whatever is being toasted.
  • Not Toasting at All:  In some cases it was reported that the toaster oven only warmed the bread,  even at the highest setting the bread was not toasted.

Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster, White

Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster, WhiteSpecifications :

  • Style: Toaster
  • Brand: Cuisinart
  • Color: White
  • Material: Plastic
  • Item Dimensions: 10.8 x 10.7 x 7.2 inches
  • Size: 4-Slice
  • Item Weight: 4.5 Pounds

Check Price on Amazon


Cuisinart’s toaster is highly regarded for its small size and ability to brown bread and bagels evenly without leaving any un-browned areas. Although it is smaller in size and costs less than our top pick, the plastic construction may not be everyone’s favorite.

You can adjust seven heat settings and reheat, freeze, and bagel settings. The slot width is 1.5 inches, so you have plenty of space to hold larger bagels. The removable crumb tray makes it easy to clean and the lever features a lift function that allows you to remove small items like French bread or English muffins from the slots. This protects your fingers.

What we liked:

  • The Price is right: Customers appreciated that this oven was reasonably priced, and gives value for money, even moreso than more expensive brands.
  • Fast Toasting: Toasting is faster with this oven give and take a minute depending on the setting, this is a plus for a number of customers that got this oven.

What we didn’t like:

  • Fire starter: Customer complained that the toaster while being used corrected cause a large fire only after a few months. While it could be the the crumbs were not emptied or many other reasons why this could have happened, it is a undesirable feature, so have course we have to make you aware of it.
  • Burnt or warm: Customers complained that even after adjusting the settings as recommended the bread comes out warm or burnt but not toasted or even close.

Breville BTA730XL Bit More 4-Slice Toaster, Brushed Stainless Steel

KitchenAid KMT4203SR Pro Line Series Specifications :

  • Brand: KitchenAid
  • Color: Sugar Pearl
  • Number of settings: 7
  • Number of Programs: 4

Check Price on Amazon


Breville makes high-quality kitchen appliances. They are also very affordable, especially considering the quality of their products. This toaster is made of stainless steel throughout. It won’t rust, corrode or become brittle and is easy to clean. This toaster is elegant and makes a strong statement on the kitchen counter. An LED monitor lets you see the progress of your toast at once. Although the lift and look function can be activated, many users complain that it doesn’t lift the toast high enough. Variable browning allows you to enjoy your toast exactly how you like it. The slots inside are large enough to hold 4 slices of your favorite bread. The standard feature of the guide is self-centering. This ensures even toasting without any burned edges or pale areas.

To give your toast the perfect finishing touch, if it pops up, you can hit the “a little more” button. You’ll also have dedicated settings for bagels or fruit bread which will give you a lot of flexibility when making breakfast. This 4-slice toaster may not be the most affordable, but the build quality and performance make it one of the best in a competitive market.

What we liked:

  • Design and look: The clean look and feel of the toaster makes it beautiful for any space. Stainless steel design with LED lights on the button, can easily make this toaster a priced appliance in the kitchen.
  • Easy to use and versatile: How easy this oven is to use is a plus for many customers, This toaster is said to toast bread, hamburger bread, whether frozen or fresh.

What we didn’t like:

  • May not be good for the long term: Customers have reported the toaster working well as much as up to a year, after that period the toaster starts malfunctioning with uneven toasting, broken dials and much more. Given the price of this unit that was not expected.
  • Oven too hot: Even with the lift and look feature some products are difficult to remove from the toaster until the oven cools. Trying to remove with a finger may result in burns.

CUSIBOX Stainless Steel Toaster

CUSIBOX Stainless Steel ToasterSpecifications :

  • Brand: CUSIBOX
  • Color: Black
  • Material: Stainless Steel
  • Item Dimensions: 11 x 9 x 6.8 inches
  • Item Weight: 4.5 Pounds

Check Price on Amazon


Cusibox may not be the first thing that comes to mind when it comes to kitchen appliances, but this large and powerful toaster is definitely worth adding to your list. Stainless steel is strong and durable. This unit is very expensive but it is currently being aggressively discounted. Grab your bargain now!

The bread slots have a long and wide opening that automatically centers your bread when it is dropped inside. You’ll love the results of this model’s toast. This toaster offers variable browning and is beginner-friendly with 6 shades to choose from If you want your toaster to be free from debris, all you have to do is to remove the crumb tray. The exterior can be cleaned with a damp cloth. You can enjoy your favorite breakfast foods, from bagels to bread, every time you press a button. What’s not love?

What we liked:

  • Convenient: Customers are impressed with how convenient this toaster with with sturdy levers, pull out crumb trays and easy clean functions. The four slots also works great for larger families as it would like less time to prepare toast for all.
  • Design: Clients are intrigued with the retro old school look of this toaster, it has been referred to as simple, cute and stylish.

What we didn’t like:

  • Broken Lever: There have been instances where the different sides of the toaster would not stay down in order for the bread to toast.
  • Sparks and gashes fire: It has been reported that on the first use the toasted would not stop sparking fire. This of course was not expected from a toaster of this price range.
  • Cheap Product:  It goes without saying that no onewants to spend money in a product that does not work. This toaster has been described as cheap quality by many reviewers for the following reasons, Thin metal, fragile mechanisms, uneven distribution of power to the heating elements. There have been reports of the product being broken upon arrival or very few uses.

KitchenAid KMT4203SR Pro Line Series

KitchenAid KMT4203SR Pro Line Series Specifications :

  • Brand: KitchenAid
  • Color: Sugar Pearl
  • Number of settings: 7
  • Number of Programs: 4

Check Price on Amazon


KitchenAid boasts a large selection of toasters, with this model from the Pro Line. What does it do when it falls and stands?

First, the sturdy stainless steel construction in a muted pearl finish makes a bold statement on the kitchen counter. However, we appreciate that you aren’t buying a toaster just for its looks. You can control each side of the toaster separately, so you can make toast for your kids simultaneously, even if they prefer different levels of browning. You can choose from six different shades, from super-dark to pale.

Bagel settings ensure that there is no need to guess or use inconsistent cooking methods when you are ready for cream cheese and smoked salmon with your favorite sourdough bagels. If you are a frequent toaster of thicker slices of artisanal or specialty bread, the large slots are great.

What we liked:

  • Branding: The Kitchenaid brand has a reputation for producing great quality products and is a trusted name among kitchen appliance. Which is another reason why customers are willing to bear the hefty price tag.
  • Nice Warming: This toaster gives ample notice once the bread is finish toasting, flashing lights and chimes.
  • Easy to maintain: This toaster is eas to be freed from finger prints and dust, the crumb tray is easy to remove and empty and the wrap cord is easy to stow away so everything is neat.

What we didn’t like:

  • Price: This toaster is very expensive, far more so that other toasters with similar qualities and features. 
  • Little longer to toast: The main drawback withthis product is that is takes a little longer to toast the bread, which is not a big deal if you are not in a hurry.
  •  Weight on this toaster: Toaster have been said to be on the heavier side. Some customer wish it were lighter and took up less space.

Stainless Steel Toaster, Yellow, Yabano

Stainless Steel Toaster, Yellow, YabanoSpecifications :

  • Brand: Yabano
  • Color: Yellow
  • Material: Stainless Steel
  • Item Dimensions: 12.5 x 12 x 7 inches
  • Wattage: 1800 watts

Check Price on Amazon



The next step is a 4-slice toaster, from a brand that may not be the first to come to your mind when you think of kitchenware. What do you get for your investment if you are willing to risk on something unknown?

This toaster’s elegant design and low profile make it a great addition to any kitchen counter. This toaster can hold 4 slices, but it is compact and space-saving. It’s great for small or cramped kitchens. There are many settings available, including cancel, defrost and reheat. Bagel settings ensure that your bagels are at their best, not burned or stuck to the sides. A stainless steel warming rack adds even more versatility to your breakfast preparations. It allows you to make delicious toasties and straight-up toast in any shade that you choose. There are 7 levels of browning available so everyone can enjoy toast as they wish. You only need to turn a dial to make it happen: What’s not to like?

What we liked:

  • Saves Time: This toaster can hold a maximum of four pieces of toast at a time. This saves a lot of times especially with larger families.
  • Pricing: This Toaster compared to others is very reasonably priced especially when we think of the features and efficiency it offers.

What we didn’t like:

  • Cheap and crappy: Customers complained that this product is cheap, material used is thin and unreliable. This has caused the entire brand to be called into question.
  • Too Hot: It has been reported that the toaster gets hot very quickly, 10 minutes after being plugged in, the toaster is too hot to the touch. 
  • Labeled dangerous product: This product is said to catch fire spontaneously, melt from the buttons with the smell of burnt plastic everytime it is used. Electrical sound and small flames have also appeared from the cord and plug area.

BUYDEEM DT-640 4-Slice Toaster

BUYDEEM DT-640 4-Slice ToasterSpecifications :

  • Brand: BUYDEEM
  • Color: Cozy Greenish
  • Item Dimensions: 12.2 x 6.97 x 11.02 inches
  • Wattage: 1800.00
  • Number of settings: 7

Check Price on Amazon


BUYDEEM, another less-known brand, has a toaster that is well worth the effort. This toaster’s pastel finish and stainless-steel build make it a great fit for both traditional and modern kitchens. These delicious treats can be made in a dedicated muffin and bagel setting. They will taste just like what you would get at a coffee shop, rather than being ruined by the heat of the oven. The BUYDEEM toasts bagels quickly by first toasting both sides. For exceptional results, toast only the cutting edge of your bagels after this initial heat burst.

These slots are self-centering so that you won’t have to worry about putting in your favorite bread. These slots are wide enough to allow thicker specialty breads to slide in without sticking to their sides. This model is known for burning toast when it’s being toasted. There are seven settings to choose from. This compact toaster can slice up to 4 pieces of toast simultaneously, but it won’t take up too much space in your kitchen.

What we liked:

  • Design and look: Customers love the retro look of this product, the design is something that anyone would want in their kitchen.
  • It actually works: Toaster is said to function very well, customers love the reheat settings and six additional settings for convenience. The functionality and the abaility to toast four slices at a time, makes it a favourite toaster in many’s book.

What we didn’t like:

  • Dial unidentifiable: After a while, the dials and writings on the toaster rubs off. This could be very convenient especially if you are not familiar with the settings or if someone new is using the toaster. 
  • Heating failed: A number of customers have reported that after a few weeks and in some cases months the product had stop heating up. While the toaster worked well for a time after a while it stop toasting all together.

Care and Maintenance

  • Electricity and liquids don’t mix. Unplug your toaster first before you try to clean it.
  • Use low heat to toast anything you haven’t toasted before. Burnt toast can be corrected with more time, but not for anyone else.
  • Do not insert a knife or any other metal object in a toaster. If you need assistance removing the toast, use wooden or plastic tongs.
  • Make sure your toaster is clean. You should clean your toaster at least once a week if you use it often.


How do I clean a toaster?

Make sure your toaster is completely cooled before you clean it. Next, take out the crumb tray. Then, shake off any crumbs and place it in a trashcan. You can wash the tray by hand if necessary. After drying, you can return it to your toaster.

To get rid of any crumbs, it’s a good idea for the toaster to be turned upside down. To remove any crumbs from the slots of your toaster, use a small brush. You can wipe down the controls and outside of your toaster with a damp cloth.

What does the number on a toaster represent?

Although the numbers on a toaster are intended to indicate how done your toast is, they can vary from one toaster to another. Different toasters have different degrees of brown toast.

The numbers on high-end toasters can sometimes be correlated with actual time. However, this is not true for all toasters. Try a few slices of bread at a time to see what the toaster does and then find the setting that suits your needs.

What is the purpose of the bagel setting in a toaster?

Toasters can be set to bagel to indicate that you are toasting thicker items, such as English muffins or bagel. These require more time to toast and heat evenly. When this function is activated, the toaster will automatically increase the time it takes to toast.

Is it possible to put foil in a toaster oven?

Aluminum foil can withstand heat but it is not recommended to be used in a toaster. Toaster slots aren’t big enough to ensure that the foil doesn’t touch the heating elements. The foil can be used in a standard oven or toaster oven.

Related Topics

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Leave a Reply