Disclaimer: Without conscious bias, we independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
To Skillet or not to skillet? To griddle or not to griddle? This can be a mental debate especially when you have gotten accustomed to cooking with a skillet. Or you may be thinking about buying a griddle and it feels out of your comfort zone.
So let me clarify. Our aim here is not to knock cast iron skillets but to enlighten you on the wide range of cooking options that you can have by taking that cast iron griddle out of the dark and letting it have some of the action. Are you not convinced?
Take one second and think of how useful your cast iron skillets have been. Now, think of using your two-burner cast iron griddle to prepare the same items. You simply cannot deny the difference. You’re able to cook way more at once with less effort in some cases.
Bedsides being able to cook more the cast-iron griddle does not have the high-rise lip, therefore you can gain easier access to whatever it is you’re cooking. Wait there’s more.. Remember those types of meats and other food items that just wouldn’t sit comfortably in the pan for a good searing or reheating? Well, like a lost final piece to an unfinished puzzle, that’s where a cast iron griddle comes in.
We can guarantee that you will add it to the top of your shopping list for your next store run if you do not already have one.
Quick List of The Best Cast Iron Griddle of 2022 and Beyond.
As mentioned before, we have utilized various ways to test the cast iron griddles. The griddles we tested include (Click on the arrow ⇩ if you would like to jump to section) :
- (⇩) – Best Overall – Lodge Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Griddle
- (⇩)– Best for beginners and new users: Lodge Pro-Grid Reversible Grill/Griddle
(⇩)– Best versatile Griddle: Cuisinart GR-B5
- (⇩) –Best in durability: Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle, 16.75 In
- (⇩) –Best for gas stovetops: Legend Cast Iron Griddle for Gas Stovetop
- (⇩) –Best in heat distribution: Calphalon 1873980 Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Grill/Griddle Combo, Black
- (⇩) – Best for Electric Stoves– OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro-Square Griddle
Tips when purchasing your cast iron griddle
One key thing to look for when purchasing a cast iron griddle is size. The most suitable size would be determined by the size of your family that you usually cook meals for.. However, even if you are not currently cooking for a large family, you may have friends over at some point. Therefore, it’s best to purchase a large enough griddle which is usually around 20 by 10.5 inches.
Another feature that you should consideris whether or not the cast iron griddle has handles. While this may seem like not a big deal ,provided you have mittens, handles on the griddle enables safer use of the item in your home, especially if you have young children around.
Another important aspect to consider is the maximum temperature the cast iron griddle can function at without damage. You can obtain this information in the “use” section of the manual/package. Also ensure that you look for details about what conditions the cast iron griddle can be used under, for example an electric stove vsgas stove vs open flame.
Finally, some griddles will state that it has been pre-seasoned. Basically, what pre-seasoned means is that the manufacturers apply a coating of wax or vegetable oil to cast iron griddle to prevent it from rusting while it sits on store shelves or in the warehouse. Even though this preventive measure was done, it is best to still season your griddle once you’ve purchased it.
How we reviewed and how were ratings awarded
The review process was mainly focused on a few key qualities that the best cast iron griddles should have. One of the main features that we looked for when we reviewed the cast iron griddles was how well they handled high temperatures. Also, we tested the quality of the griddles to see how well they cooked food items without sticking and how well they retained heat.
In order to generate a more balanced review and to ensure ratings were awarded fairly, we utilized focus groups for selected periods during product testing. These focus groups were individuals whom provided reports, ratings, and reviews which gave us details on the quality of the product, the size and other features. Amazon reviews on cast iron griddles were also included in the review and rating process.
In the end we narrowed it down to the top seven. Four of these cast iron griddles we actually tested and 3 were based on Amazon reviews.
The complete list of the Best Cast Iron Griddles
The cast iron griddle that tops our list is the famous Lodge Pre-seasoned cast iron griddle. The Lodge company has a long history of producing griddles of amazing quality and durability. This cast iron griddle is wide, round-shaped, and measures 10.5 inches. This lodge griddle comfortably provides ample space for cooking and is designed specifically to allow the consumer to easily prepare meals. One of the best things about this Lodge griddle is that it has excellent heat retention and can be used both indoors and outdoors. , So feel free to start planning your next backyard barbecue.
- Lowered and leaned sidewalls.
- Oven safe
- Used on indoor and outdoor surfaces
- Takes some to heat up
There are a lot of awesome features to this Calphalon product. It’s great for outdoors and indoors use, and it’s pre-seasoned. But here’s the best part, not only is it a griddle, but it also has a reversible side that allows you to grill your favourite meals! The versatility of this two-in-one product allows you to make from basic meals to fancy meals all with one piece of cookware.
The Calphalon grill/griddle is designed to handle high temperatures on various surfaces. It can withstand heats up to 1500F however the seasoning will only burn off at 800F. Therefore, you can feel safe that this griddle can more than withstand the heat of your oven. The grill also possesses excellent heat retention and distribution, ensuring that foods are evenly cooked within optimal time.
- Pre-seasoned surface.
- Oven and broiler safe.
- Consistent heat distribution.
- Very heavy
- Layout is inconvenient.
This griddle will make cooking some of your favourite meals a pleasure because of its excellent non-stick feature. It also offers the consumer versatility, enabling them to cook various types of meals, whether in the oven or on top of the stove. Another user friendly feature about this OXO griddle is that it is dishwasher safe which makes clean-up after a meal a breeze.
- Oven safe
- Dishwasher safe
- Non-stick feature
- Non-stick feature degrades.
- Warping occurs eventually
Lodge products gained popularity over the decades because of their excellent reputation for producing quality products. This reversible grill/griddle is no exception. This product provides ample space for the consumer to prepare meals on both sides. It also distributes heat very well, which enables the consumer to evenly cook meals.
- Extremely durable
- Wide cooking surface
- Reversible grill features
- Cracking tends to occur.
Cuisinart has been able to market its products as some of the best among other kitchenware giants. This modern multiple feature griddle can cause excitement among seasoned cooks.
Not only does it provide multiple cooking options, but it is also fairly easy to clean and is made with sturdy materials, including stainless steel. Whether it’s a typical evening meal of a succulently grilled chicken sandwich or a date night dinner of juicy steak and grilled veggies, this Cuisinart Model can make the perfect meal to sit perfectly at your dinner table.
- Reversible griddle/grill
- Dishwasher safe
- Floating cover
- Loud control sounds
- Delicate button/knobs
The Legend brand speaks for itself when it comes to quality products. While this cast iron griddle may not be as versatile as other brands, its longevity is unmatched by many of the fancier models.
This Legend product is made with iron and quality grade steel which in turn provides the consumer with excellent heat distribution.
It was originally designed for gas stoves however this griddle can also get an awesome bonfire party going with its reversible grill which can be used for cooking burgers over an open campfire.
- Excellent durability
- Reversible griddle/grill
- Handles for easier use
- Incompatible with induction stoves
We are ending this list on a high note with this two-in-one pre-seasoned cast iron grill/griddle. Yes, Lodge made the cut again. Lodge hardly disappoints. They have decades of experience in manufacturing cast iron products, how could they? This product not only enables even heating but also durability and, versatility. This grill/griddle can be used on any heat source and is perfect for cooking up a storm in the backyard with family and neighbours or for a simple lunch indoors with the kids.
- Comes pre-seasoned
- Excellent Durability
- Smooth surface
- Heat distribution takes time
- Incompatible with induction stovetops
Safety precautions when cooking?
Griddles open the door to creating memorable cooking and family experiences. However, like many other kitchen equipment, incorrect use, lack of care, and maintenance can cause hazards.
We have some safety precaution tips that we implore you to follow to keep you and your family safe while preparing your favourite meals.
- Ensure the griddle is secured on a stable surface that is clear of other objects and hazards
- Ensure that the instructions are followed on how to regulate temperatures when using the griddle to avoid overheating
- When the griddle is in use, keep children and animals away from the area.
- During cooking, always use protective cooking gears to avoid burns, especially if you need to adjust or move the griddle. Also remember to keep these gears away from the open flame.
- Before attempting to clean the griddle, ensure that it has cooled down enough that you can touch it with your bare hands.
- Follow the instructions and guidelines on how to clean the griddle from grease and food particles since a build-up can result in fires.
- Ensure that your home and cooking area are equipped with the correct extinguisher category to extinguish a fire.
If you are cooking outdoors, the best option to extinguish a fire is to use sand or dirt.
We have given you specifications and our view on seven of the best griddles on the market. We also discussed some safety precautions. However, in order to gain an even greater level of trust and confidence in the griddle that you do eventually purchase you need to also look at the overriding brand of the product itself. The 5 brands you can rely on are:
When you hear the word Lodge visions of a bed and breakfast may come to mind. Just like those memories can last a lifetime Lodge also boasts of the same effect: “We don’t just make cookware — we make memories that last for generations.”
Lodge Cast Iron was originally founded in South Pittsburg, Tennessee and has been making cookware and accessories for the past 125 years. They specialize in making ONLY cast-iron cookware. They take pride in their manufacturing process which uses a proprietary mix of iron, steel and other ingredients to make their products.
Cuisinart has become an established name for kitchen appliances and more. The brand is owned by Conair Corporation. The Cuisinart company was originally created to introduce the food processor to the American market back in 1971. Today Cuisinart offers more than food processors. Its product offering includes appliances, bakeware, cookware, outdoor grilling and more.
So, what makes a Cuisinart griddle special? Cuisinart has 50 years of expertise in development, designing and making quality products that are easy to use. So, you can rest assured this griddle was created with the consumer in mind.
Legend cookware is a newbie to the cookware industry. The company was registered 3 years ago. However, in this fast-paced technological era we are all too familiar with new entrants being able to create waves in a market (Ahemm Tik Tok was only launched globally 3 years ago as well).
This company is based in New York but services customers worldwide. So, what makes Legend cookware a legend? Their products are made up of high-quality materials which last longer. Also, they specifically cater to the modern cook with the main focus being on delicious meals prepared.
They currently offer cast iron and stainless-steel cookware with plans to launch enamelled and carbon products soon.
Calphalon is located in Ohio and was founded 58 years ago. It originally targeted the restaurant industry with aluminium cookware. However, what sets this company apart from the rest was when its founder invented hard-anodized aluminium cookware in 1968, using a process adopted from the aerospace industry that makes cookware more durable and resistant to corrosion and warping.
The company has since then evolved into the leading producer of premium-quality cookware, bakeware, cutlery, and appliances for the home chef credited
OXO is a New York based company who has been serving the market for 30 years. They offer products in four main categories: cooking and baking, beverage preparation, cleaning & organisation and baby & toddler. Even though their product offering is diverse they are very unique at their core.
Their motto is “We Believe in a Better way.” They accomplish this by looking at everyday objects and activities for pain points i.e look for problems people don’t realize until they are solved. This is why the OXO griddle made the cut as its unique feature is the rolled side edges for drip free pouring.
So, should there be a mental debate between the iron skillet and iron griddle? We would say no, the choice boils down to a matter of preference. Whether you’re an experienced cook or someone who occasionally cooks out of necessity, cast iron griddles are a must-have. Durability and excellent heat retention are a guarantee, and depending on the brand and model selected; you will also enjoy the versatility and other amazing features.
Of course, some may need more care and maintenance to produce the best results for years to come. Nevertheless, every penny spent will be worthwhile. With the introduction of these seven excellent brands and models, we have no doubt that you will have an easier time exploring and selecting your cast iron griddle!