Buying Guide

Gourmia vs Ninja Foodi: Which Air Fryer Is Better?

Disclaimer: Without conscious bias, we independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Ninja and Gourmia are two of the most reputable brands in the air frying industry. Are they really as good as they claim or is it just hot air? You’re in the right place to find out! I’ve done the research, I’ve tested them both and now I can tell you all you need to know before buying one of these air fryers. Here’s what this article covers:

  • Performance testing
  • Pricing
  • Ease of use
  • Cleaning
  • What I like and dislike

All that and more will be covered so keep reading to get the full scoop.

Why you should trust us?

Each product we examine is put through its paces for days, weeks, and sometimes months. We recognize that consumers have a right to know everything there is to know about a product before deciding whether or not to buy it. We reach out to industry experts and manufacturers, and best of all, we put the items to the test ourselves.

I have spent many hours testing kitchen appliances, in addition to being a home cook. Just recently, I spent hours testing out two other air fryers so this isn’t my first rodeo. I know exactly what to look for so you can make an educated decision about the Gourmia versus the Ninja Foodi Cooker. I chose specific foods for the test in order to get the most accurate results. Before we dive in, you should know that the Ninja Foodi air fryer that I’m reviewing is model OP302 which is almost exactly like the OP301 except this one gas a dehydrator function.

Gourmia 6 Quart Digital Air Fryer GAF698

Specifications :

  • Brand: Gourmia
  • Capacity: 6 Quarts
  • Item Weight: 5.42 Kilograms
  • Control Method: Touch
  • Has Nonstick Coating: Yes

Check Price on Amazon

Ninja OS301 Foodi 10-in-1 Pressure Cooker and Air Fryer

Specifications :

  • Brand: Ninja
  • Model name: OS301 Foodi 10-in-1
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Capacity: 6.5 Liters
  • Item Dimensions 13.58 x 13.58 x 12.99 inches
  • Weight : 27.68 Pounds

Check Price on Amazon

Comparison Chart

Model

Gourmia Digital Fryer

Ninja Foodi Air Fryer

Brand

Gourmia

Shark Ninja

Capacity

6 Quartz

6.5 Quartz

Item Weight

11.92 Pounds

24.3 pounds

Color

Stainless Steel

Black

Founded

2015

1993

Where It’s Made

China

China

Voltage

120-220 Volts

220 Volts

Wattage

1400 watts

 1400 watts

Dishwasher Safe

Yes

Yes

Functions

12

8

Non-stick Coating

Yes

Yes

Dimensions

‎ 15.1 x 13.6 x 13.3 inches

 14.25 x 16.75 x 13.1 inches

How we tested both air fryers?

I’ve conducted cooking tests with other air fryers so I know what foods specifically will help me determine which model performs best. Chicken wings, frozen fries and vegetables are great for testing which model heats more evenly, if the pre-set temperatures are accurate enough to thoroughly cook food and also to determine which tastes better.

Chicken Wings

I was ecstatic that the preheat function was not mandatory for either of these air fryers. I seasoned and air fried the wings for 28 minutes. The Gourmia alerted me to turn them halfway through the cooking so I rem9ved the air fry basket and gave it a few shakes to turn the wings. I cooked the wings in the Ninja Foodi based on the temperature charts and recipe in the cookbook. I must say results lived up to the hype of both models. The wings were crispy and they had an evenly browned colour. The only real difference was the wings from the Gourmia were a little dry.

I wanted to see how well the Ninja Foodi’s crisper and pressure cooker lids worked together, so I pressure cooked another batch of wings for 18 minutes before switching to the crisper lid for another 10 minutes. In total, it took more time to pressure cook and air fry than just to air fry. This is because the Foodi had to build up pressure for 7 minutes before the actual countdown started. The wings came out juicier with this method but just air frying is faster.

White Sandwich Bread

Like I’ve done with previous cooking tests, I placed 4 slices of white sandwich bread in each model. After toasting, I compared the outcomes. This toast function on the Gourmia was no more accurate than the instructions from the Ninja Foodi cookbook.  This is a common drawback of most air fryers with pre-sets. In any case, I much rather to trifle with the timing in order to get the desired crust.

Frozen French Fries

I’ve always had a love hate relationship with French fries. You have to fill a skillet with oil and keep an eye on it but the taste was always worth it. Since I’ve joined the air fryer craze I get to enjoy crispy fries with just a brush of oil.

The Gourmia could hold 2 pounds of fries easily and I wanted to test if  the fries would be cooked evenly and with a nice crispy exterior. I was satisfied with the results from both models but the Ninja Foodi definitely did a better job of crisping the fries. Using the Gourmia’s turn food function isn’t mandatory but I would recommend it if you’re filling the basket.

Vegetables

I used the steam function on the Ninja Foodie to cook the carrots, zucchini and eggplants I chose for the cooking test. All vegetables were cooked thoroughly and tasted great. I also tried the pressure cooker function on a handful of the veggies and they turned out a little softer and of course took longer.

In comparison, the results from the vegetables function on the Gourmia left a lot to be desired. A few of the carrots were not cooked through and that indicated that this model doesn’t heat evenly. Overall, I was satisfied with both tests.

Key differences

Difference 1: Design

The Gourmia has a non-stick, all plastic interior with bright LED lights. The four tiny feet of the crisper tray are silicone and I had to bend them inwards a little to fit in the basket. The appliance is also surprisingly light for its size. One thing to note is the horrible plastic smell the moment you start to unbox. The user’s manual said it could smell like that for up to 5 uses. A few other air fryers I reviewed had the same burning plastic smell and doing a few test runs cleared it up.

I noticed that the hot air vent is at the back but thankfully it doesn’t get too hot during cooking. I’m not fond of the round shape of the basket but it’s about 6 inches in height and can hold a 5 pound chicken easily. It would be great for baking. The Ninja Foodi will sit like a giant on your kitchen counter and that’s acceptable for me because it can replace a crockpot, toaster oven and a dehydrator. There is a knob at the top for sealing or venting steam when the pressure cooker function has been activated. Always use oven mittens to hold it to release the steam. The knob gets really hot.  A red button is inserted in an outlet next to it. When the air fryer is under enough pressure, that button will appear.

The cooking pot is non-stick and quite sturdy. I like that the air frying rack is reversible so you can choose if your food is closer to the bottom of the pot or at the top. The keep warm function is also pretty nifty because it counts upwards to show how long the food is being kept warm. I’ve tried other Ninja air fryers and I must say the biggest drawback is that the crisper lid cannot be removed. If you have the pressure cooker lid on, the crisper lid awkwardly hangs open.

Difference 2: Company History

When Mark Rosenweig and his parents started SharkNinja in 1994, the company was initially known as Euro-Pro. The name refers to two aspects of the business. Shark began as a manufacturer of household cleaning appliances, but in 2015 they expanded into the Ninja kitchen appliance line. The Ninja Foodi range includes five air fryers that differ in size, function, and design. SharkNinja created a name for itself in the business by pioneering the air fry function.

Gourmia is headquartered in Brooklyn, New York and was founded by Heshy Biegeleisen. “We design them to bring professional-chef techniques to every home kitchen, making healthy gourmet meals easier to achieve.” Those are the words of Heshy as he talked about the Gourmia brand. Along with air fryers, the brand produces ice cream makers, kettles, coffee grinders, dehydrators and pressure cookers.

Difference 3: Where It Is Made

Both models are made in China as most kitchen appliances are.

Difference 4: Collections

There are five models in the Ninja Foodi air fryer collection.

Gourmia Collection

Difference 5: Capacity

At 6.5 quarts, the Ninja Foodi no doubt has a larger capacity than the Gourmia’s 6 quarts. The cooking pot can fit a 6 pound roast easily but the air fryer basket has a capacity of 4 quarts.

Difference 6: Controls

I like that with the Gourmia it alerts you to turn food half way through cooking. It also has preheat and add food alerts that pop us on it’s fancy LED screen. The number of pre-sets are a bit excessive in my opinion but I like that they are separated because in some models you have to press one button multiple times to see the options. Once it’s plugged in, you have to put the basket in or the unit will not turn on. Once the basket is attached then the blue control panel with light up and you can press the power button.

Difference 7: Cleaning

The Gourmia Air Fryer was very easy to clean. No matter how messy the basket and rack gets, the non-stick coating protects them. I used a paper towel to wipe it down then used a sponge and dish soap. It’s also dishwasher friendly. easiest of the two to clean. All the removable components of the Ninja Foodi are dishwasher safe including the basket and accessories. The air fryer lid can’t be removed as I said earlier so I wiped it down by hand. You’ll need a flexible brush to clean between the actual lid and the grate if it gets too messy.

Difference 8: Noise

This Ninja Foodi model is not as loud as previous ones I’ve tested and even with the pressure cooker function on it’s no louder than a hair dryer. I did notice a popping sound the first time I used the pressure cooker function and after some research I found out it was normal. Once the lid heats up and the glass and stainless steel begin to expand somewhat, resulting in a noise. Because of the alerts to preheat, add food and turn food, the Gourmia makes a lot of annoying beeps throughout cooking. Otherwise, the noise level is about 65 decibels, about the same as a small vacuum cleaner.

Ninja foodi noise testing video:

Gourmia noise testing video:

Difference 9: Warranty and Guarantees

If you purchase the Ninja Foodi from authorized retailers like Amazon, Cosco or Walmart, a one year warranty will cover repairs or the replacement of your model. SharkNinja will replace defective air fryers with one of equal or greater value. This warranty does not cover normal wear and tear of wearable parts (such as blending vessels, lids, cups, blades, blender bases, removable pots, racks, and pans), which require regular maintenance and/or replacement to guarantee correct operation of your machine. At ninjaaccessories.com, you may purchase replacement parts.

SharkNinja will pay to have your air fryer shipped to them but they will charge a return fee. The same conditions apply to Gourmia’s 1 year limited warranty. You will have to register your model on their website to get assistance with replacements.

Difference 10: Price

It’s no secret that the Ninja Foodi is on the more expensive size and it’s not surprising either. The price quoted on Amazon is $235 but you can also compare prices at Costco and Walmart to try and get a better deal. With all the offerings of this huge air frying wonder, the value is well worth the price.

With the Gourmia Air Fryer you get what you pay for. At $109 on Amazon I feel it is a fair trade for a decent air fryer. At Costco you can even get it for less than $100. If you’re one a tight budget and you’re not looking to replace other single use items, this may be for you.

Difference 11: Dehydrator

I couldn’t conclude this review without talking about the dehydrator function on the Ninja Foodi. You can dehydrate fruits, meats, vegetables and even flowers with this function. The only drawback of the dehydrator is that you can only do it in small batches and each batch will take at least 4 hours depending on the crisping that you desire. Another popular use for the dehydrator is to make yoghurt. There is a recipe in the cookbook.

Bottom Line: Should you buy the  Gourmia Digital Fryer or Ninja Foodi Cooker?

Before I tell you my recommendation, let’s do a quick recap of what I covered.

  • The Ninja Foodi has more unique functions even though the Gourmia has more in number. Pressure cooking and dehydrating are special functions of the Ninja.
  • When compared in price, the Ninja Foodi is more expensive because of the added functions and exceptional performance. It costs $235 at Amazon but other authorized sellers will have different prices. The Gourmia really functions as a glorified air fryer and not much else so the price of $109 is fair.
  • Both models have easy to use controls and cleaning is only difficult with the Ninja Air Fryer. It excels in performance by heating food evenly and producing a better crisp than the Gourmia Air Fryer.
  • The Gourmia has one 6 quart air frying basket while the Ninja Foodi has a 6.5 quart cooking pot and a 4 quart air frying basket.

Being one of the few air fryers out there that has the dehydrator function, and with such exceptional performance overall, my recommendation is the Ninja Foodi. It not only saves on space by replacing single function appliances but it also saves time by being faster than conventional methods of cooking.

While the Gourmia is a great air fryer with many functions, it doesn’t perform as well compared to the Ninja Foodie. I also think 12 functions are a bit overkill when the only difference between the pre-sets is the timing.

Gourmia Air Fryer FAQ

Can it cook a whole chicken?

Yes, it can fit a whole 6 pound chicken in the cooking pot and a 5 pound if you use the air fryer basket.

Does it have Teflon?

Yes, they use Teflon coating to prevent rust and sticking.

Is the baking function any good?

Yes, the baking function is great because of how tall the basket is and how well the model regulates heat.

Ninja Foodi Cooker FAQ

Can it make yoghurt?

Yes! The dehydrate function is perfect for making yoghurt. You can check the cookbook for a recipe.

Can I cook two dishes at once?

Yes, there are settings and recipes for doing just that.

Is it possible to bake a cake in the Ninja Foodi?

Yes, it does have a bake function and recipes for cakes, cookies etc. However, you will need a baking pan that fits in the air fryer.

Does it leak with the pressure cooker function?

Only if you put too much water in the pot will it leak out of the top. I usually use one cup of water for less than an hour of pressure cooking.

Similar resources:

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Leave a Reply